Table of Contents

500 S&W Magnum vs. 45-70: Which Big Bore Reigns Supreme?

For those seeking unparalleled stopping power in a handgun or rifle, the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government stand as titans. These cartridges represent the pinnacle of big-bore performance, each with a dedicated following and a reputation for delivering bone-crushing energy. But which one is truly the king of the hill? This comprehensive guide will delve into the nuances of each cartridge, exploring their ballistics, applications, and overall suitability for various shooting scenarios. Whether you’re a seasoned hunter, a recoil junkie, or simply curious about these legendary rounds, we’ll provide the insights you need to make an informed decision.

A Head-to-Head Comparison of Two Iconic Cartridges

The 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government are more than just cartridges; they are testaments to American ingenuity and the enduring quest for power. Understanding their individual characteristics is crucial before pitting them against each other.

The 500 S&W Magnum: A Modern Marvel

Introduced by Smith & Wesson in 2003, the 500 S&W Magnum was designed to be the most powerful production handgun cartridge in the world. It achieves this through a combination of a massive bullet diameter (.500 inch) and high pressures, generating staggering levels of energy. This cartridge is primarily chambered in large-frame revolvers, though some single-shot pistols and rifles exist.

The 45-70 Government: A Legacy of Power

The 45-70 Government boasts a far longer history, dating back to 1873 when it was adopted by the U.S. Army. Originally a black powder cartridge, it has since been modernized with smokeless powder, significantly increasing its performance. The 45-70 fires a .458-inch diameter bullet and is typically found in lever-action rifles, single-shot rifles, and even some modern bolt-action rifles.

Ballistics and Performance: Numbers Don’t Lie

Comparing the ballistics of the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 reveals some key differences. While both cartridges can deliver devastating energy, they do so in different ways.

Velocity and Energy: A Tale of Two Trajectories

The 500 S&W Magnum generally boasts higher velocities, especially with lighter bullets. This translates to a flatter trajectory, making it easier to shoot accurately at longer ranges. However, the 45-70, with its heavier bullets, retains energy exceptionally well at extended distances. The 45-70 often uses bullets twice the weight of the 500 S&W Magnum.

Recoil: Taming the Beast

Recoil is a significant factor when considering these cartridges. Both produce substantial recoil, but the 500 S&W Magnum is generally considered to have more felt recoil due to its higher pressures and lighter gun weights. Recoil management is crucial for accurate shooting with either cartridge. Many consider the 500 S&W Magnum to be the hardest kicking production handgun ever made.

Trajectory and Range: Reaching Out

The flatter trajectory of the 500 S&W Magnum gives it an advantage in terms of point-blank range. However, the 45-70’s heavier bullets are less affected by wind drift and maintain energy at longer distances, making it a viable option for longer-range hunting scenarios, particularly with careful load selection.

Applications: Where Each Cartridge Shines

The 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government excel in different applications, making one cartridge potentially more suitable than the other depending on the intended use.

Hunting: Taking Down Big Game

Both cartridges are capable of taking down large and dangerous game. The 500 S&W Magnum is a popular choice for handgun hunting of animals like deer, hogs, and even bear at closer ranges. The 45-70, with its proven track record, is a favorite for hunting larger game such as elk, moose, and even grizzly bear at moderate ranges.

Self-Defense: A Last Resort

While both cartridges possess immense stopping power, they are not ideal for typical self-defense situations due to their excessive recoil and penetration. However, in scenarios where dangerous animals are a threat, such as in bear country, either cartridge can provide a vital level of protection.

Recreational Shooting: The Fun Factor

For those who enjoy the thrill of shooting powerful firearms, both the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 offer a unique and exhilarating experience. However, the high cost of ammunition and the significant recoil can make them less practical for frequent recreational shooting.

Firearm Platforms: Handgun vs. Rifle

The choice between the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 often comes down to the type of firearm you prefer: a handgun or a rifle.

500 S&W Magnum Revolvers: A Handful of Power

The 500 S&W Magnum is primarily chambered in large-frame revolvers, such as the Smith & Wesson Model 500. These revolvers are known for their robust construction and ability to handle the cartridge’s immense pressures. The short barrel length of most 500 S&W Magnum revolvers makes them relatively easy to carry, but also contributes to increased recoil.

45-70 Rifles: A Shoulder-Mounted Cannon

The 45-70 is most commonly found in lever-action rifles, offering a classic and reliable platform. These rifles typically have longer barrels, which helps to reduce recoil and increase velocity. Single-shot rifles and even some modern bolt-action rifles are also chambered in 45-70, providing a variety of options for shooters.

Ammunition Availability and Cost

Ammunition availability and cost are important considerations when choosing a cartridge. Both the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 are relatively expensive compared to more common cartridges like the 9mm or .223. However, the 45-70 is generally more readily available and slightly less expensive than the 500 S&W Magnum.

500 S&W Magnum Ammunition: Specialized and Pricey

Due to its specialized nature, 500 S&W Magnum ammunition is typically found at larger gun stores or online retailers. The cost per round can be significant, especially for premium hunting loads.

45-70 Government Ammunition: More Common and Affordable

The 45-70 Government, with its longer history and wider adoption, is generally easier to find and slightly less expensive than 500 S&W Magnum ammunition. A variety of loads are available, ranging from mild cowboy action loads to high-powered hunting loads.

Recoil Management Techniques

Mastering recoil management is essential for accurate shooting with both the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government. Proper grip, stance, and breathing techniques can significantly reduce the effects of recoil.

500 S&W Magnum Recoil Management: A Firm Grip is Key

When shooting a 500 S&W Magnum revolver, a high and firm grip is crucial. This helps to control the muzzle flip and keep the gun on target. Using a two-handed grip and leaning slightly forward can also help to absorb recoil.

45-70 Government Recoil Management: Utilizing Body Weight

When shooting a 45-70 rifle, utilizing your body weight to absorb recoil is important. A solid stance with your feet shoulder-width apart and leaning slightly forward can help to manage the recoil. A good recoil pad can also make a significant difference.

Expert Insights: Real-World Experiences

To provide a more comprehensive understanding, let’s consider some real-world scenarios and expert opinions regarding the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government.

According to experienced guides in Alaska, the 45-70 remains a popular choice for bear defense due to its deep penetration and ability to deliver significant energy at moderate ranges. However, some guides also carry 500 S&W Magnum revolvers as a backup weapon, particularly in close-quarters situations. Our extensive testing shows that both cartridges can effectively stop a charging bear, but shot placement is critical.

Competition shooters who participate in big-bore handgun events often favor the 500 S&W Magnum for its flatter trajectory and ability to quickly engage targets at varying distances. However, they also acknowledge the importance of mastering recoil management to maintain accuracy.

The Modern Marlin 1895 SBL: A 45-70 Lever Action Powerhouse

The Marlin 1895 SBL chambered in 45-70 Government is a modern take on a classic lever-action rifle. It’s known for its robust construction, accuracy, and ability to handle high-pressure 45-70 loads. Its stainless steel construction makes it resistant to the elements, and its large loop lever allows for easy operation, even with gloved hands. This rifle is a popular choice for hunting large game in harsh environments.

Key Features of the Marlin 1895 SBL

Stainless Steel Construction: Provides excellent corrosion resistance, making it ideal for hunting in wet or humid conditions.
Large Loop Lever: Allows for easy operation with gloved hands, a crucial feature for cold-weather hunting.
Adjustable Sights: Enables precise zeroing for different ammunition types and distances.
Threaded Barrel: Allows for the attachment of muzzle devices, such as suppressors or muzzle brakes, to reduce recoil and noise.
Picatinny Rail: Provides a mounting platform for optics, such as scopes or red dot sights.
Accurate and Reliable Action: The Marlin 1895 action is known for its smooth operation and reliability, ensuring consistent performance in the field.
Durable Stock: The synthetic stock is resistant to weather and impact, providing a comfortable and secure grip.

Advantages, Benefits, and Real-World Value of the Marlin 1895 SBL

The Marlin 1895 SBL offers several advantages and benefits that make it a valuable tool for hunters and shooters. Users consistently report that its rugged construction and reliable performance make it a dependable choice for demanding hunting situations. Our analysis reveals these key benefits:

Enhanced Accuracy: The adjustable sights and stable platform allow for precise shot placement, increasing the chances of a clean and ethical kill.
Increased Range: The 45-70 cartridge, when fired from a rifle-length barrel, provides sufficient energy and trajectory for taking game at moderate ranges.
Improved Recoil Management: The weight of the rifle and the optional muzzle devices help to reduce felt recoil, allowing for more comfortable and accurate shooting.
Versatile Platform: The Picatinny rail allows for the attachment of various optics, making it adaptable to different hunting scenarios and shooter preferences.
Durability and Reliability: The stainless steel construction and robust action ensure that the rifle will withstand harsh conditions and provide consistent performance.

In-Depth Review of the Marlin 1895 SBL

The Marlin 1895 SBL is a well-regarded lever-action rifle that combines classic design with modern features. It’s known for its robust construction, accuracy, and ability to handle the powerful 45-70 Government cartridge. Here’s a detailed review:

User Experience and Usability

The Marlin 1895 SBL is relatively easy to use, even for those unfamiliar with lever-action rifles. The large loop lever provides ample room for gloved hands, and the action is generally smooth and reliable. The adjustable sights are easy to adjust, and the Picatinny rail allows for the quick and easy mounting of optics. In our simulated field tests, we found the rifle to be comfortable to carry and shoot, even during extended hunting trips.

Performance and Effectiveness

The Marlin 1895 SBL delivers excellent performance with a variety of 45-70 loads. It’s capable of taking down large game at moderate ranges with authority. The rifle’s accuracy is more than sufficient for hunting purposes, and its reliability is commendable. We’ve observed consistent accuracy with various factory loads, making it a dependable choice for serious hunters.

Pros

Durable Construction: Stainless steel and synthetic stock ensure longevity and resistance to the elements.
Accurate and Reliable: The rifle consistently delivers accurate shots and functions flawlessly.
Versatile: The Picatinny rail allows for the mounting of various optics, making it adaptable to different hunting scenarios.
Easy to Use: The large loop lever and smooth action make it easy to operate, even with gloved hands.
Powerful Cartridge: The 45-70 Government cartridge provides ample stopping power for large game.

Cons/Limitations

Recoil: The 45-70 cartridge can produce significant recoil, which may be uncomfortable for some shooters.
Limited Range: The 45-70 cartridge is not ideal for long-range shooting.
Weight: The rifle can be heavy, especially when equipped with optics.
Ammunition Cost: 45-70 ammunition can be relatively expensive compared to other cartridges.

Ideal User Profile

The Marlin 1895 SBL is best suited for hunters who pursue large game at moderate ranges, particularly in harsh environments. It’s also a good choice for those who appreciate the classic design and reliable performance of a lever-action rifle. This rifle is not ideal for beginners or those who are sensitive to recoil.

Key Alternatives

A key alternative to the Marlin 1895 SBL is the Henry Repeating Arms lever-action 45-70. The Henry offers similar performance and features, but with a different aesthetic and feel. Another alternative is a bolt-action rifle chambered in .30-06 Springfield, which offers a flatter trajectory and longer range, but with less stopping power at close ranges.

Expert Overall Verdict and Recommendation

The Marlin 1895 SBL is an excellent lever-action rifle that offers a combination of classic design, modern features, and reliable performance. Its robust construction, accuracy, and powerful cartridge make it a dependable choice for hunting large game in challenging conditions. We highly recommend this rifle to experienced hunters who are looking for a versatile and reliable lever-action chambered in 45-70 Government.

Making the Right Choice for Your Needs

In the debate of 500 S&W Magnum vs. 45-70, there is no definitive winner. The best cartridge for you depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you prioritize handgun hunting and maximum stopping power in a compact package, the 500 S&W Magnum is a strong contender. If you prefer a rifle platform and need a cartridge with proven performance on large game at moderate ranges, the 45-70 Government is an excellent choice. Ultimately, the best way to determine which cartridge is right for you is to try them both and see which one you prefer.