Table of Contents

500 S&W Magnum vs. 45-70: Which Big Bore Reigns Supreme?

The debate rages on among big bore enthusiasts: 500 S&W Magnum or 45-70 Government? Both cartridges are titans of power, capable of taking down virtually any game animal on Earth. But their similarities often obscure crucial differences that make one a better choice than the other, depending on your specific needs and priorities. This comprehensive guide dives deep into the nuances of each cartridge, exploring their ballistics, recoil, applications, and much more, providing you with the knowledge to make an informed decision. We’ll explore the strengths and weaknesses of each, helping you determine which cartridge truly reigns supreme for your purposes.

A Head-to-Head Comparison of Two Legendary Cartridges

The 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government are often mentioned in the same breath, but they are fundamentally different cartridges designed for different purposes. Understanding these differences is key to choosing the right one.

The 500 S&W Magnum: Modern Powerhouse

The 500 S&W Magnum is a relatively recent development, introduced in 2003 by Smith & Wesson. Its primary design goal was to create the most powerful handgun cartridge available, capable of taking down large and dangerous game. It achieves this through a combination of a massive bullet diameter (.500 inch) and high pressures. This cartridge is most commonly found in large-frame revolvers.

The 45-70 Government: A Historic Heavy Hitter

The 45-70 Government, on the other hand, has a long and storied history, dating back to 1873 when it was adopted by the U.S. Army. It was initially designed for single-shot rifles and was used extensively in the Indian Wars. While originally a black powder cartridge, modern loadings use smokeless powder and can achieve impressive velocities and energies. It’s most commonly found in lever-action rifles, though single-shot rifles are also common.

Ballistics and Performance: Numbers Tell the Tale

Comparing ballistic data is crucial for understanding the capabilities of each cartridge. Several factors influence this, including bullet weight, bullet type, and barrel length. Here’s a general overview:

Velocity: The 500 S&W Magnum generally boasts higher velocities, especially with lighter bullets. This translates to a flatter trajectory and potentially longer effective range.
Energy: Both cartridges generate tremendous energy, but the 500 S&W Magnum often edges out the 45-70 in terms of muzzle energy, particularly with heavier loads.
Trajectory: The 45-70 typically has a more curved trajectory due to its lower velocity and heavier bullets. This requires more precise range estimation, especially at longer distances.
Effective Range: While both are capable of taking down game at considerable distances, the 500 S&W Magnum, in a rifle platform, generally offers a flatter trajectory, making it easier to shoot accurately at extended ranges. The 45-70 is typically considered a shorter-range cartridge, especially in its traditional lever-action rifles.

It’s important to note that ballistic performance varies significantly depending on the specific load. Always consult reputable ballistics charts and consider your intended use when selecting ammunition.

Recoil: Taming the Beast

Recoil is a significant factor to consider with both of these powerful cartridges. Neither is for the faint of heart. However, the *type* of recoil differs, and perceived recoil is highly subjective.

500 S&W Magnum Recoil: Often described as sharp and violent. The recoil is concentrated in a shorter timeframe due to the higher pressures. In a handgun, this can be especially brutal.
45-70 Government Recoil: Typically described as a heavy push. The recoil is spread out over a longer duration, making it feel less sharp but equally powerful.

Several factors influence perceived recoil, including gun weight, stock design (for rifles), grip design (for handguns), and the shooter’s individual tolerance. Muzzle brakes and recoil pads can help mitigate recoil in both platforms.

Applications: Where Each Cartridge Shines

The intended use case plays a crucial role in determining which cartridge is best suited for your needs.

500 S&W Magnum Applications

Hunting Dangerous Game: The 500 S&W Magnum is a popular choice for hunting large and dangerous game, such as bear, boar, and even African game. Its immense power ensures quick and ethical kills.
Handgun Hunting: The 500 S&W Magnum is a favorite among handgun hunters due to its ability to deliver rifle-like power in a relatively compact package.
Backup Gun: Some hunters and guides carry a 500 S&W Magnum as a backup gun for protection against dangerous animals.

45-70 Government Applications

Hunting Large Game: The 45-70 is a proven performer on large game animals, including deer, elk, and moose.
Brush Hunting: Its heavy bullets and moderate velocities make it well-suited for hunting in dense brush, where shots are typically at closer ranges.
Historical Re-enactments: The 45-70 is a popular choice for historical re-enactors and black powder enthusiasts.
Cowboy Action Shooting: Some cowboy action shooting disciplines allow for the use of 45-70 rifles.

Firearm Availability and Cost

The availability and cost of firearms chambered in each cartridge can also influence your decision.

500 S&W Magnum Firearms: Primarily found in large-frame revolvers, such as the Smith & Wesson Model 500. Some single-shot rifles are also available, but they are less common.
45-70 Government Firearms: Commonly found in lever-action rifles, such as the Marlin 1895 and Henry rifles. Single-shot rifles, such as the Ruger No. 1, are also popular.

Generally, 45-70 firearms are more readily available and often less expensive than 500 S&W Magnum firearms. Ammunition costs can vary depending on the specific load, but 45-70 ammunition is often slightly less expensive.

Ammunition Selection: Choosing the Right Load

The choice of ammunition is critical for both cartridges. Different loads offer varying levels of performance and are designed for specific purposes. Here are some considerations:

500 S&W Magnum Ammunition

Bullet Weight: 500 S&W Magnum ammunition is available in a wide range of bullet weights, typically ranging from 275 to 700 grains.
Bullet Type: Options include jacketed hollow points (JHPs) for hunting thin-skinned game, hard cast bullets for penetrating thick hides, and full metal jacket (FMJ) bullets for target shooting.

45-70 Government Ammunition

Bullet Weight: 45-70 Government ammunition is available in bullet weights ranging from 300 to 500 grains.
Bullet Type: Options include jacketed soft points (JSPs) for hunting, hard cast bullets for deep penetration, and lead round nose (LRN) bullets for plinking.

Always consult reputable reloading manuals and ballistics charts when selecting ammunition. Consider your intended use and the game you’ll be hunting when making your choice.

500 S&W Magnum: The Pinnacle of Handgun Power

The 500 S&W Magnum stands as a testament to modern cartridge design, specifically tailored for delivering maximum power from a handgun platform. Its development focused on achieving unparalleled energy transfer and stopping power, making it a top choice for hunters pursuing dangerous game. The cartridge’s design allows for a wide range of bullet weights and types, catering to diverse hunting scenarios. Its large diameter (.500 inch) ensures significant tissue damage upon impact, contributing to rapid incapacitation of the target. The 500 S&W Magnum is not merely a cartridge; it’s a carefully engineered system designed to deliver unmatched performance in demanding situations.

Exploring the Key Features of the 500 S&W Magnum

The 500 S&W Magnum’s design incorporates several key features that contribute to its exceptional performance:

Large Case Capacity: The large case allows for a substantial powder charge, enabling high velocities and energy levels. This is crucial for achieving the cartridge’s signature stopping power.
.500-inch Bullet Diameter: The wide bullet diameter creates a large wound channel, maximizing tissue damage and increasing the likelihood of a quick, ethical kill.
High SAAMI Pressure: The cartridge is designed to operate at high pressures, allowing for greater velocities and energy transfer. This requires robust firearm construction.
Versatile Bullet Selection: A wide variety of bullet weights and types are available, allowing shooters to tailor their ammunition to specific hunting needs.
Magnum Primer: A magnum primer ensures reliable ignition of the large powder charge, even in cold weather conditions.
Thick Case Walls: The case walls are thicker than those of many other handgun cartridges, providing added strength and durability.
Controlled Expansion Bullets: Many 500 S&W Magnum loads feature controlled expansion bullets, which are designed to expand reliably upon impact while maintaining sufficient penetration.

Each of these features contributes to the 500 S&W Magnum’s reputation as one of the most powerful and effective handgun cartridges ever developed.

Advantages of the 500 S&W Magnum: Performance and Versatility

The 500 S&W Magnum offers several distinct advantages for hunters and shooters:

Unmatched Stopping Power: Its ability to deliver massive energy on target makes it ideal for taking down large and dangerous game quickly and ethically.
Versatility in Ammunition Selection: The wide range of available bullet weights and types allows shooters to tailor their ammunition to specific hunting needs and preferences.
Effective Range: While primarily a handgun cartridge, the 500 S&W Magnum can be effective at surprisingly long ranges with proper technique and ammunition selection.
Proven Performance: It has a proven track record of success in the field, with countless hunters relying on it to take down a variety of game animals.
Availability: Although powerful, the cartridge is widely available at most gun stores and online retailers.

A Critical Look: Limitations of the 500 S&W Magnum

Despite its many advantages, the 500 S&W Magnum also has some limitations:

Extreme Recoil: The recoil can be punishing, especially in lightweight handguns. This requires significant practice and experience to master.
High Ammunition Cost: Ammunition can be expensive compared to other handgun cartridges.
Large Firearm Size: Firearms chambered in 500 S&W Magnum are typically large and heavy, making them less comfortable to carry for extended periods.
Overpenetration: The cartridge’s immense power can lead to overpenetration, especially on smaller game animals.

These limitations should be carefully considered before choosing the 500 S&W Magnum.

Who is the 500 S&W Magnum Best Suited For?

The 500 S&W Magnum is best suited for experienced shooters who are comfortable with heavy recoil and are looking for maximum stopping power in a handgun. It’s a popular choice for hunting dangerous game, such as bear and boar, and for those who want a reliable backup gun for protection in the wilderness. It’s less suitable for beginners or those who are recoil-sensitive.

Alternatives to the 500 S&W Magnum

Alternatives to the 500 S&W Magnum include the 460 S&W Magnum and the 454 Casull. The 460 S&W Magnum offers similar performance with slightly less recoil, while the 454 Casull is a smaller cartridge with a more manageable recoil. However, neither offers quite the same level of stopping power as the 500 S&W Magnum.

Choosing the Right Big Bore: Making the Informed Choice

In the final analysis, the choice between the 500 S&W Magnum and the 45-70 Government depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you’re looking for maximum handgun power for hunting dangerous game or as a backup gun, the 500 S&W Magnum is an excellent choice. If you prefer a rifle cartridge for hunting large game at moderate ranges, the 45-70 Government is a proven performer. Consider your intended use, recoil tolerance, and budget when making your decision. Both cartridges are capable of delivering impressive performance in the right hands.