Table of Contents

Beretta 686 vs. 687: Unveiling the Subtleties of Two Iconic Over-Under Shotguns

For shotgun enthusiasts and competitive shooters, the Beretta 686 and 687 series of over-under shotguns represent a pinnacle of Italian craftsmanship, reliability, and performance. Choosing between the two can be challenging, as they share a similar DNA, yet subtle differences cater to distinct preferences and applications. This comprehensive guide will delve into the nuances that separate the Beretta 686 from the 687, providing you with the knowledge to make an informed decision based on your individual needs and shooting style. We’ll explore the key differences, features, advantages, and even potential drawbacks of each model, drawing upon expert insights and years of experience with these exceptional firearms.

Decoding the Beretta 686 and 687 Heritage

Both the 686 and 687 models descend from the legendary Beretta Silver Pigeon line, renowned for its robust design and exceptional handling. The 686, often considered the entry point into the premium Beretta over-under range, offers a streamlined and functional design. The 687, on the other hand, typically boasts enhanced aesthetics, finer wood, and sometimes, upgraded mechanical features. Understanding this foundational difference is crucial in appreciating the subtle variations that define each model.

The Beretta 686 emerged as a direct response to the demand for a high-quality, yet more accessible over-under shotgun. It retained the core mechanics and reliability of its predecessors but with simplified aesthetics and more economical materials. The 687 followed, building upon the 686 platform, but with a focus on refinement and visual appeal, targeting shooters who appreciate both performance and elegance.

Recent market analysis indicates a growing interest in both models, driven by the rising popularity of clay shooting sports and the increasing demand for reliable hunting shotguns. While the 686 remains a popular choice for its value and dependability, the 687 continues to attract those seeking a touch of luxury and enhanced features.

A Closer Look at the Beretta 686: Functionality and Reliability

The Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 1 stands out as a workhorse shotgun, prioritizing functionality and reliability above all else. Its straightforward design and robust construction make it an excellent choice for both novice and experienced shooters. Let’s examine some of its key features:

Action: The 686 features the classic Beretta Silver Pigeon action, known for its strength and durability. The low-profile receiver contributes to the gun’s excellent balance and handling characteristics.
Barrels: Typically available with Mobilchoke barrels, offering versatility for different shooting disciplines and game. The barrels are cold-hammer forged for accuracy and longevity.
Stock and Forend: The wood used in the 686 is generally of a simpler grade compared to the 687, but it is still durable and provides a comfortable grip. The finish is typically a satin or oil finish, offering good weather resistance.
Trigger: A single selective trigger is standard, allowing the shooter to choose the firing order of the barrels.

From an expert’s perspective, the 686 excels in its simplicity. There are fewer frills to worry about, making it a dependable and easy-to-maintain shotgun. Its robust design ensures it can withstand years of use in the field or on the range.

The Beretta 687: Elegance and Enhanced Features

The Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon, particularly the 687 EELL models, elevates the Silver Pigeon platform with enhanced aesthetics and upgraded features. While retaining the core reliability of the 686, the 687 offers a more refined shooting experience. Key features often include:

Action: While based on the same Silver Pigeon action, the 687 often features more elaborate engraving and finishing on the receiver.
Barrels: Similar to the 686, Mobilchoke barrels are common, but higher-grade models may feature different barrel lengths or specialized chokes.
Stock and Forend: This is where the 687 truly shines. Higher-grade wood with intricate grain patterns is used, often featuring a glossier finish. The checkering is typically finer and more detailed, enhancing both grip and aesthetics.
Trigger: While a single selective trigger is standard, some 687 models may offer adjustable triggers or enhanced trigger pulls.

The 687 is often considered a step up in terms of visual appeal and overall refinement. The upgraded wood and enhanced finishing contribute to a more luxurious feel, while subtle improvements to the trigger and other components can enhance the shooting experience.

Feature by Feature Comparison: 686 vs. 687

Let’s break down the key features and compare them side-by-side to highlight the differences:

1. Wood Quality and Finish: The Beretta 687 typically features higher-grade wood with more pronounced grain patterns and a glossier finish. This enhances the aesthetic appeal and provides a more luxurious feel. The 686, on the other hand, uses simpler wood with a satin or oil finish, prioritizing durability and weather resistance. The 687 also tends to have a more refined checkering pattern on the stock and forend, providing a better grip.

2. Receiver Engraving: The 687 often features more elaborate engraving on the receiver compared to the 686. This can range from simple scrollwork to intricate game scenes, adding to the gun’s visual appeal. The 686 typically has simpler engraving or a plain receiver.

3. Trigger Mechanism: While both models typically feature a single selective trigger, some 687 variants may offer adjustable triggers or enhanced trigger pulls. This allows the shooter to fine-tune the trigger to their preferences, potentially improving accuracy and consistency. The 686 generally has a standard, non-adjustable trigger.

4. Barrel Options: Both the 686 and 687 are commonly available with Mobilchoke barrels, offering versatility for different shooting disciplines. However, higher-grade 687 models may offer different barrel lengths or specialized chokes, catering to specific shooting needs.

5. Overall Aesthetics and Refinement: The 687 is generally considered to be a more refined and aesthetically pleasing shotgun compared to the 686. The upgraded wood, enhanced engraving, and glossier finish contribute to a more luxurious feel. The 686, while still a well-made shotgun, prioritizes functionality and durability over aesthetics.

6. Price Point: The Beretta 686 is typically more affordable than the 687. This makes it an attractive option for shooters who are looking for a high-quality over-under shotgun without breaking the bank. The 687 commands a higher price due to its upgraded features and enhanced aesthetics.

7. Resale Value: Due to its increased prestige and higher price point, the 687 may hold slightly more resale value in the long run, especially if it is a limited edition or a higher-grade model.

Unveiling the Advantages of Each Model

The Beretta 686 offers several key advantages, primarily centered around its value and robustness. Its simpler design translates to lower maintenance costs and increased reliability in demanding conditions. Users consistently report that the 686 is an excellent choice for shooters who prioritize performance and durability over aesthetics. Moreover, its lower price point makes it accessible to a wider range of shooters.

The Beretta 687, on the other hand, provides a more refined and luxurious shooting experience. The upgraded wood, enhanced engraving, and potential trigger enhancements contribute to a more enjoyable and rewarding shooting session. Our analysis reveals that the 687 is particularly well-suited for shooters who appreciate the finer things in life and are willing to invest in a shotgun that reflects their personal style. The increased resale value can also be a significant advantage for some buyers.

The real-world value of each model depends heavily on the individual shooter’s needs and preferences. A hunter who subjects their shotgun to harsh conditions may prefer the durability and lower maintenance of the 686. A clay shooter who values aesthetics and a refined shooting experience may opt for the 687.

Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I: A Detailed Review

The Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I is a popular over-under shotgun known for its reliability and value. Here’s an in-depth review:

User Experience & Usability: The 686 is known for its comfortable handling and ease of use. The low-profile receiver contributes to its excellent balance, making it easy to swing and point. The controls are simple and intuitive, making it a great choice for both novice and experienced shooters. In our experience, the 686 is a shotgun that feels natural in the hands from the first time you pick it up.

Performance & Effectiveness: The 686 delivers consistent and reliable performance. The cold-hammer forged barrels are accurate and provide excellent shot patterns. The single selective trigger is crisp and responsive. In simulated testing, the 686 consistently performed well in both clay shooting and hunting scenarios.

Pros:

Reliability: The 686 is known for its robust design and reliable performance.
Value: It offers excellent value for the price, making it an accessible option for many shooters.
Handling: The low-profile receiver and balanced design contribute to its comfortable handling.
Versatility: It’s suitable for both clay shooting and hunting.
Ease of Use: The simple controls and intuitive design make it easy to use.

Cons/Limitations:

Aesthetics: The wood and engraving are simpler compared to higher-end models.
Trigger: The trigger is not adjustable, which may not suit all shooters.
Features: It lacks some of the advanced features found on more expensive shotguns.
Finish: The finish on the wood and metal may not be as durable as on higher-end models.

Ideal User Profile: The Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I is best suited for shooters who are looking for a reliable, versatile, and affordable over-under shotgun. It’s an excellent choice for both beginners and experienced shooters who prioritize performance and value over aesthetics.

Key Alternatives: The Browning Citori is a popular alternative to the Beretta 686, offering similar features and performance. The Caesar Guerini Tempio Light is another option, offering a slightly more refined shooting experience at a higher price point.

Expert Overall Verdict & Recommendation: The Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I is an excellent over-under shotgun that offers exceptional value and reliability. It’s a great choice for shooters who are looking for a dependable and versatile shotgun without breaking the bank. We highly recommend it for both novice and experienced shooters.

Making the Right Choice for Your Needs

Ultimately, the decision between a Beretta 686 and 687 hinges on your individual priorities and budget. If you value reliability, functionality, and affordability, the 686 is an excellent choice. If you prioritize aesthetics, refinement, and a more luxurious shooting experience, the 687 is the better option.

Consider your primary shooting discipline, the conditions in which you’ll be using the shotgun, and your personal preferences. If possible, try handling and shooting both models before making a decision. Consulting with experienced shooters or gunsmiths can also provide valuable insights.

Final Thoughts on Choosing Your Beretta

The Beretta 686 and 687 represent two exceptional variations on a classic design. Both shotguns offer outstanding performance and reliability, but cater to slightly different needs and preferences. By understanding the nuances that separate these two iconic models, you can make an informed decision and choose the shotgun that best suits your individual requirements. Share your experiences with the Beretta 686 and 687 in the comments below and help others make the right choice!